Lumanora vs the rest. One platform, a flat monthly fee.
How Lumanora compares with ERPs, merchant-of-record services and shipping platforms, on what each provider publishes.
Lumanora compared with four ERPs: Cin7, Business Central, NetSuite and Apparel21
Scored on 20 needs of a Shopify brand selling abroad. Lumanora’s score counts what we build for you on request, each marked.
- Each need scored out of 5, then weighted and rounded to a total out of 100
How it works
- We scored 20 needs of a Shopify brand selling abroad. Buyer research sets the weights; for the five cross‑border needs, our judgement does.
- Features: a 4 or 5 earns full points, a connector, add‑on or partner 60%, a related feature 30%, not offered nothing.
- Cost, go‑live, ease of use, support, security, track record and customisation earn their share: a 4 of 5 earns 80%.
- Lumanora’s total counts what we build for you on request, each marked. The ERPs are scored as they are today.
- Lumanora’s answers are our own account of its platform; the ERPs’ rest on their own pages, reviews and research.
The scale, for features
- 5 of 5: Built in, complete
- 4 of 5: Built in, with limits, or built on request
- 3 of 5: Connector, add-on or partner
- 2 of 5: A related feature
- 1 of 5: Not offered or not stated
Costs
- ERP costs are our estimates over three years: licences, add‑ons, the Shopify connector, set‑up and partner support. Lumanora’s is its starting price, by the modules you use.
- They leave out tax filing (Avalara, about US$1,400 a month) and shipping or returns apps. Lumanora’s tax services are quoted separately.
What each need weighs, out of 100
Cost and getting started weighs most (39 of 100); total cost is the heaviest single need (10).
- Cost and getting started, 39 points:
- Total cost, 10
- Shopify connection, 9
- Go‑live time, 8
- Ease of use, 6
- Support and onboarding, 6
- Selling across borders, 18 points:
- Customs codes, 4
- International shipping, 4
- Tax and local entity, 4
- Duty per product, 3
- Returns, 3
- Running the business, 26 points:
- Inventory and orders, 7
- Accounting, 6
- Purchasing and suppliers, 6
- Margin reporting, 4
- Multi‑currency, 3
- Trust and room to grow, 17 points:
- Track record, 4
- Customisation, 4
- Security certification, 3
- Security in practice, 3
- Wholesale and B2B, 3
-
88 out of 100
- Cin7 81 out of 100
- Business Central 74 out of 100
- NetSuite 71 out of 100
- Apparel21 65 out of 100
| | Cin7 | Business Central | NetSuite | Apparel21 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Score out of 100 | 88 out of 100 | 81 out of 100 | 74 out of 100 | 71 out of 100 | 65 out of 100 |
| | Commerce operating system For Shopify brands selling abroad Platform: In your browser, on a modern web stack (Next.js 16, React 19). | Inventory and order management | Finance, sales and operations | Cloud ERP, with an apparel version | Fashion and footwear ERP |
| Cost and getting started | |||||
| 4 of 5: From US$2,500 a month Tax services quoted separately Priced by the modules you use. Sources2 | 4 of 5: About US$2,000 a month (estimate) List price US$349–1,199 a month | 3 of 5: About US$3,500 a month (estimate) List price US$80–110 a user a month | 1 of 5: About US$8,000 a month (estimate) List price not published | 2 of 5: About US$6,000 a month (estimate) List price not published | |
| Why it counts: Integration problems are the most common disruption when a new system goes in (40%), and for a Shopify brand every order starts in Shopify. Weighs 9 of 100 Sources18 | Built in: Two‑way sync, customs codes too Orders and refunds flow in; stock and customs codes go back. One Shopify store per account; tracking updates on the way. | Built in: Cin7’s own two‑way sync | Built in: Microsoft’s free connector | Through a connector, partner or add-on: Paid connector from Oracle | Through a connector, partner or add-on: Apparel21’s own connector |
| 5 of 5: Live in under a month From signed order form to first live order, by our records. Switched on by our team, with no partner project. | 4 of 5: About 1 to 3 months | 3 of 5: About 2 to 6 months | 3 of 5: About 3 to 6 months | 2 of 5: About 6 to 9 months Led by its own consultants: “six to nine months”, in its words. Sources32 | |
| 3 of 5: Looks like Shopify’s admin | 4 of 5: Core easier to use than most | 3 of 5: A learning curve, users say | 3 of 5: A learning curve, users say | 3 of 5: No independent ratings | |
| 3 of 5: Email to our team, business hours | 3 of 5: 24/7 chat and tickets | 3 of 5: Through your partner | 3 of 5: Weekdays; 24/7 costs extra | 4 of 5: Its own team, after‑hours line | |
| Selling across borders | |||||
| Built in: Customs codes for every market A code suggested for every product from our own customs database, its confidence scored; expert review on request. Kept per market and written back to Shopify. | A related feature: A code field, synced | A related feature: Codes you enter, synced | A related feature: A code field you fill in | Not offered: No customs code stated | |
| Built in: Booking, labels, export papers A paperless commercial invoice; suppliers sign export papers in their portal. Booked with your own carriers, with a manifest and pickups. | Through a connector, partner or add-on: Labels through shipping apps | Through a connector, partner or add-on: Labels through partner apps | Built in: Its own app, Ship Central | Through a connector, partner or add-on: Labels through a shipping integration | |
| Why it counts: VAT is the second most reported hurdle for firms selling online across the EU, and US sales tax means registering state by state. Weighs 4 of 100 Sources95 | 4 of 5: US LLC and sales tax, managed Your US LLC as merchant of record, its IRS filings and sales tax. A managed service, quoted separately. | 2 of 5: Sales tax via Avalara | 2 of 5: VAT returns; US via Avalara | 2 of 5: UK VAT filed; US via Avalara | 2 of 5: Calculates GST, VAT and US tax |
| Why it counts: 40% of US shoppers who abandon a cart cite extra costs, so a brand needs each product’s duty to build it into the price. Weighs 3 of 100 Sources102 | Built on request, 4 of 5: More markets, built on request Duty, tax and fees for each product into the US today. More markets set up on request; not yet added at checkout. Today: A US duty estimate per product | A related feature: Landed cost on purchases | A related feature: Extra costs on purchases | A related feature: Landed cost on stock received | A related feature: Shipment costs on purchases |
| Built in: Its own returns portal Prepaid return labels, no customs form for your customer. Refund or store credit, and every return tracked. Sources108 | Built in: Returns portal, Advanced plan | Through a connector, partner or add-on: Through a returns partner app | Built in: Returns built in; portal via partner | Through a connector, partner or add-on: Online returns via partners | |
| Running the business | |||||
| Why it counts: Three of the seven signs a brand has outgrown Shopify and its apps are about orders, stock and warehouses (eightx). Weighs 7 of 100 Sources118 | 4 of 5: Stock, orders and fulfilment Live stock by location, synced to Shopify. Shopify POS sales arrive with all your other orders. | 4 of 5: Unlimited stock locations | 4 of 5: Locations, bins and warehouses | 4 of 5: Every location, in real time | 5 of 5: Stores, warehouses and POS |
| Built on request, 4 of 5: Ledger built on request A basic ledger, built for you when you ask. A Xero link is on the way. Today: Bookkeeping by our in‑house team Sources2 | Built in: Basic ledger; Xero, QuickBooks | Built in: Full finance in every plan | Built in: Full ledger and consolidation | Built in: Ledger, bills and invoices | |
| Built on request, 4 of 5: Purchasing, built on request Purchase orders to suppliers today, priced in their own portal. Stock orders, received with freight and duty, and kits: built on request. Today: Purchase orders to suppliers | 5 of 5: Buying and production planning Purchase orders on every plan; production planning from Pro. Advanced production is an add‑on. Sources4 | 5 of 5: Buying; production on Premium | 5 of 5: Supplier portal and production | 5 of 5: Buying, shipments, production | |
| Why it counts: Reporting tools were the most deployed project in Panorama’s 2026 study. Weighs 4 of 100 Sources45 | Built in: Profit per product and per order Common Cents: profit on every order after every cost. Today: Live sales, stock and profit per product | Built in: Gross profit on every order | Through a connector, partner or add-on: Profit reports in Power BI | Built in: Estimated gross profit per order Shown on every order; its help notes “Landed costs are excluded”. Sources144 | Through a connector, partner or add-on: Margin reports in Insight |
| | Built on request, 4 of 5: Multi‑currency, built on request Multi‑currency accounting, built for you when you ask. Today: Orders keep the shopper’s currency beside your store’s. | Built in: Multi‑currency on every plan | Built in: Many currencies, Shopify’s too | Built in: 190+ currencies, in OneWorld With exchange rates, across every company in the group. Sources132 | Built in: Store currencies, built in |
| Trust and room to grow | |||||
| 2 of 5: A newer platform In use by merchant stores, with fewer reviews than the others. Rated 5.0 on G2 so far Source: G2.com, Inc. Sources53 | 5 of 5: Over 8,500 customers | 5 of 5: Used by 55,000 companies | 5 of 5: Over 44,000 customers | 4 of 5: 40+ years, 125+ retailers | |
| 4 of 5: Built on request, by our team Modules switched on for you; changes built by our own team, quoted before we start. Sources151 | 3 of 5: Some fields; more via partners | 3 of 5: Extensions built by partners | 4 of 5: Deep, with admin or developer | 3 of 5: Some rules; more via partners | |
| 2 of 5: SOC 2 audit commencing 2027 Our hosting, database, sign‑in and email providers are each SOC 2 Type II audited. Sources3 | 5 of 5: SOC 2 Type II compliant | 5 of 5: SOC 2 Type II, ISO 27001 | 5 of 5: SOC 1 and 2, ISO 27001 Externally audited; also ISO 27018, 42001 and PCI DSS for cards. Sources167 | 5 of 5: ISO 27001 certified Certified since August 2024; its scope and any SOC report not stated. Sources168 | |
| Why it counts: Beyond a certificate, 62% of organisations require multi‑factor sign‑in or other secure access from their suppliers (ISC2, 2025). Weighs 3 of 100 Sources162 | 4 of 5: Encrypted, kept apart, every change logged | 4 of 5: Two‑step sign‑in, full audit report | 5 of 5: Own database, Microsoft sign‑in | 4 of 5: Single sign‑on and tested recovery | 3 of 5: Two‑step sign‑in, on your servers |
| Built on request, 4 of 5: Wholesale, built on request Wholesale orders by tier, status and payment; no ordering portal. Today: Set up for you on request | Built in: Wholesale; portal an add‑on | Built in: Customer pricing; Shopify B2B | Built in: Wholesale; storefront add‑on | Built in: Wholesale suite, SalesNet |
Where Lumanora leads.
-
A full commerce operating system
Orders, stock, shipping, customs, tax, returns and margin, run as one platform.
-
Lumanora Flow, on the way
Rules and approvals that run on their own, from purchase orders to fulfilment.
-
Common Cents
What you make on every order, after duty, freight, payments and returns.
-
A leading customs database
Every product classified against 928,552 sourced tariff lines, with expert review on request.
-
Every carrier, one booking
Your own carriers, your data mapped once, every export booked with its papers.
-
Built for Shopify, built to change
Its own Shopify app on the current API, changed by our own developers.
-
Experts in US expansion
Your US LLC as merchant of record, filings and sales tax, quoted separately.
-
UK VAT, managed for you
Registration and quarterly returns handled by our team, as a managed service quoted separately.
-
India’s exports, automated
One export pack for Indian customs, then the e‑way bill after booking.
| | Merchant-of-record services | A stack of apps | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pricing | Yes: The platform, from US$2,500 a month
| ||
| Seller of record | Yes: You, or your own entity
| ||
| Checkout | Yes: Your Shopify checkout
| Yes: Stays yours16 | |
| Customer data | Yes: You keep ownership
| Varies by provider | |
| Duties and taxes | Yes: In your price, worked out per product
| ||
| Product classification | Yes: Every product, classified
| Varies by provider | |
| Local entities | Yes: Formed and run by Lumanora
| Varies by provider | |
| Returns and tracking | Yes: A prepaid label in under 60 seconds
| ||
| Number of tools | Yes: One system
| Varies by provider |
USA profitability calculator. Your own entity, or a merchant of record.
Monthly saving
US$10,598
With your own US entityUS$127,176 a year
| Typical merchant of record 6% US$13,098 a month | Your own US entity Lumanora platform US$2,500 a month | |
|---|---|---|
| Fee, 6% | US$13.10 an order | US$2,500 a month |
| Charged on the whole order | US$218.30 an order | |
| Entity, filings and sales tax | Quoted separately | |
| Duty | US$43.50 an order | US$43.50 an order |
| Per order, US$ | ||
| Goods | 150.00 | 150.00 |
| Shipping | 12.00 | 12.00 |
| Insurance1% | 1.50 | 1.50 |
| Duty29% | 43.50 | 43.50 |
| Sales tax7.53% | 11.30 | 11.30 |
| Landed price | 218.30 | 218.30 |
| Fee | 13.10 | 2.50 |
Estimates from published fees and the US tariff schedule. Fees vary by contract; not tax or customs advice. Sources
- Duty applies from the first dollar: the industry’s base rate plus the origin’s Section 301 tariff. The EU, Japan, South Korea and Switzerland are topped up to their caps.
- Insurance (from 1%) and sales tax (from 7.53%) are worked on the goods, with shipping from US$12 an order. Each provider’s percentage is charged on its own base: the whole order, the goods or the duty.
- Typical merchant of record, 6%, is a typical rate, not a quote: published fees range from 4% of goods to 8% of the whole order.
- Your own entity pays the Lumanora platform fee, from US$2,500 a month, shared across the month’s orders. Managed tax and compliance services are quoted separately and are not in this figure. Its duty is on the import value: retail at 100%, or a wholesale share of it.
- Left out on every route: card processing, and your own entity’s customs bond, broker and bookkeeping.
- Global-e (SEC filing) Record fourth quarter and full year 2025 results (opens in a new tab) Published, 18 February 2026
- Global-e Docs Reconciliation report overview (opens in a new tab) Published, 9 November 2026
- Global-e Docs UK merchants with non-Global-e carriers (opens in a new tab) Reported, 9 November 2026
- Shopify International pricing (opens in a new tab) Published, 9 November 2026
- Shopify Help Center Managed Markets payouts (opens in a new tab) Published, 9 November 2026
- Swap Swap vs Global-e (opens in a new tab) Published, 9 November 2026
- Zonos Docs Landed cost pricing (opens in a new tab) Published, 9 November 2026
- Reach What is a merchant of record? (opens in a new tab) Published, 12 October 2022
- US International Trade Commission Harmonized Tariff Schedule, 2026 Revision 22 (opens in a new tab) Published, 30 October 2026
- Office of the US Trade Representative Action in the forced labor Section 301 investigations (opens in a new tab) Published, 23 July 2026
- Baker Donelson Forced labor Section 301 tariffs: what importers need to know (opens in a new tab) Reported, 24 July 2026
- Zonos US tariff updates (opens in a new tab) Reported, 26 October 2026
- Tax Foundation State and local sales tax rates, midyear 2026 (opens in a new tab) Published, 6 July 2026
Lumanora vs shipping platforms. Shipping is one part of it.
Sources. Each provider’s own pages.Their own pages, reviews and research.
| No. | PublisherSource | Page |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Vendr | Avalara pricing (opens in a new tab) |
| 2 | Lumanora | Commerce, but intelligent. (opens in a new tab) |
| 3 | Lumanora’s providers | Their own security pages Fly.io (opens in a new tab)Neon (opens in a new tab)Clerk (opens in a new tab)Resend (opens in a new tab) |
| 4 | Cin7 | Cin7 Pricing | Inventory Software Price for Core & Omni Plans (opens in a new tab) |
| 5 | Cin7 | Security policy: Security and Compliance (opens in a new tab) |
| 6 | Microsoft | Dynamics 365 Business Central (opens in a new tab) |
| 7 | Microsoft Learn | Service Compliance and SLA, Business Central (opens in a new tab) |
| 8 | Microsoft Learn | Update cycles, Business Central (opens in a new tab) |
| 9 | PR Newswire | Oracle NetSuite release of 26 Oct 2026 (opens in a new tab) |
| 10 | Oracle NetSuite Help Center | Supported Browsers for NetSuite (opens in a new tab) |
All product and company names are trademarks of their respective holders.
Fees and features as each provider published them on 9 and 10 November 20269, 10 and 12 November 2026; check each provider for current terms.